Best Innerspring Mattresses

There are good ways to get that well-deserved quality sleep, and your bed has a major thing to say about that, specifically the innerspring mattresses that have been around for over a 100 year already. Innerspring remains on the top spot for the most popular mattress type, but this doesn’t necessarily mean they have high customer approval and satisfaction rating, nevertheless. The most important things that we look for in an innerspring mattress (and you should too) include mattress density, the type, the number of coils used, motion transfer, and temperature sensitivity.

Top 10 Rated Innerspring Mattresses of 2017

What exactly is an innerspring mattress? This mattress type is commonly known as spring mattress, and it is mainly made up of coils for its internal construction and has 3 other components namely the support base layer, the comfort layer, and the fabric cover for the first cushion.

ProductDurabilitySleep QualityTrial PeriodPriceScore
Beautyrest Recharge Hybrid Bound Brook Ultimate Luxury Plush Mattress
Beautyrest Recharge Hybrid Bound Brook Ultimate Luxury Plush Mattress

9.6
9.2
0
$$$$
2 Zinus 10 Inch Performance Plus, Extra Firm Spring Mattress
Zinus 10 Inch Performance Plus, Extra Firm Spring Mattress

9.2
9.4
30
$$
Best seller
3 Signature Sleep Contour 8-Inch Independently Encased Coil Mattress Review
Signature Sleep Contour 8-Inch Independently Encased Coil Mattress Review

8.3
8.5
30
$$
Best price
4 Sleep Master Ultima Spring Mattress Review
Sleep Master Ultima Spring Mattress Review

8.5
8.4
30
$
5 Olee Sleep Hybrid Gel Infused Memory Foam Innerspring Mattress
Olee Sleep Hybrid Gel Infused Memory Foam Innerspring Mattress

8.8
9.1
100
$$
6 DreamFoam Bedding Ultimate Dreams Twin Crazy Quilt with 7-Inch TriZone Mattress
DreamFoam Bedding Ultimate Dreams Twin Crazy Quilt with 7-Inch TriZone Mattress

8.7
8.8
90
$
Best value
7 Classic Brands Advantage Hybrid Mattress
Classic Brands Advantage Hybrid Mattress

8.4
8.6
30
$
8 Signature Sleep 13 Inch Independently Encased Coil Mattress
Signature Sleep 13 Inch Independently Encased Coil Mattress

8.9
8.5
30
$$
9 Night Therapy 13 Inch Spring Euro Box Mattress
Night Therapy 13 Inch Spring Euro Box Mattress

8.7
8.3
30
$$
10 Englander Finale 10-Inch Innerspring Mattress Review
Englander Finale 10-Inch Innerspring Mattress Review

8.3
8.5
30
$

How to Choose the Best Innerspring Mattress?

Coil System and Foam Layers

Innerspring mattresses are not created equal, but they do have a common denominator when it comes to their basic construction and layering particularly with the coil system and their distinct foam layers that may vary according to the type of foams and fabrics used. The support base or coil system layer is the spring core made from steel springs or also known as coils or coil springs, and the number of coils would vary with different manufacturers. The comfort layer of the mattress is also referred to as the upholstery layer that is the topmost level, made up of numerous types of foams or fibers such as latex, gel memory foam, polyurethane foam, and visco-elastic, offering cushion at the surface for optimal comfort. The last layer is the fabric cover which encases the entire mattress and may come with different materials such as polyester yarn, wool, silk, rayon, and cotton.

back to menu ↑

Coil Types

Coil spring mattresses differ in the coil design and pattern that is utilized within the spring bed, all having different effects on the overall quality and firmness level of the unit.

  • Open Coils: This type of spring mattress is more commonly known as the Bonnell and the oldest and most widespread coil spring system that is used for cheaper mattresses, consisting mainly of multiple tempered steel springs with hourglass shapes that are laced together, forming the main bulk or body of the bed structure.
  • Continuous Coils: The structure of the rows of coil springs is molded into springs that run through the width and length of the bed, making the structure of the long tempered steel wire a good option for its conforming ability and motion isolation.
  • Offset Coils: The more expensive innerspring mattress version compared to its Bonnell counterpart, offset coil beds have similar design and structure types, but the individual springs are hinged together to ensure better body contouring and motion transfer.
  • Pocket Spring: The pocket spring or pocket coil mattress consists of hundreds or thousands of independently wrapped springs using different types of fabric or cloth, making it one of the best innerspring mattresses due to its superior support, longevity, and motion transfer.
back to menu ↑

Mattress Firmness

The firmness of the innerspring mattress is secured through factors such as the gauge of the coils, whereas the mattresses with a much lower gauge number have much thicker coils. For instance, mattresses with 12.5 gauge coils are significantly firmer compared to those with 15.5 gauge coils, and so on. The coil gauge also delivers different levels of bouncing effect on the mattress, whereas lower coil gauges are firmer and higher gauges have a softer or bouncier impact. In the previous 5 decades, the standard coil count for a queen-sized bed is 800 coils which offer enough support for two people who weigh not more than 800 lbs. You can determine the appropriate coil count for your mattress through comparing it with foam weights, qualities, and types.

Testing the mattress for firmness requires you to spend at least 10 minutes on different spring mattress types and determine the pros and cons of each unit.Of course feeling comfortable is the most important factor but it’s also crucial to have proper body alignment.  Spinal alignment is a factor which simply can’t be neglected, even if not now, later it will cause back pain. Here is the illustrated version of how “Just right” mattress should be.

choosing mattress firmness

back to menu ↑

Heat-Trapping, Motion Transfer, Edge Support, Off-Gassing

The different coil types of the mattress typically have their corresponding features especially when it comes to heat trapping, edge support, and motion transfer. The degree of support, heat transfer and motion isolation depends on what type of construction the mattress has. Open coil mattresses have lesser to average motion isolation, support, heat retention, and durability compared to higher end models such as pocket spring mattress beds. But regardless of the coil type, spring mattresses absorb heat pretty well due to their metallic nature and sleeping cool factor is better than in hybrid and foam mattresses (especially memory foam).

Innerspring mattresses have above-average motion transfer compared to latex and memory foam mattresses that have high-density base layers. Providing more support and equal weight distribution, so that you would not disturb the person lying next to you when you toss and turn or get off the bed. The heat retention of innerspring depends on the comfort layer that is combined, as there are hybrid models that have latex, poly foam, or memory foam blends. The fabric cover of the innerspring also contributes to the coolness of the mattress.

Edge support for spring beds depends on the mattress’ coil construction since there are coil spring beds that can withstand an enormous amount of pressure and weight with minimal to unnoticeable sagging issues. Innerspring mattresses do have certain features that could compete with the durability of its latex and memory foam counterparts, especially pocket spring mattresses with the innovative technology that is used for individually wrapped coil springs, however, the result would still be relatively different, depending on the user’s weight and body frame.

Memory FoamLatexInnersping
Durability
81 %
Durability
84 %
Durability
75 %
Odor
82 %
Odor
76 %
Odor
72 %
min. Motion
88 %
Motion t.
77 %
Motion t.
73 %
cool sleep
67 %
cool sleep
83 %
cool sleep
70 %
edge support
81 %
edge support
82 %
edge support
84 %

Durability of Innerspring Mattresses

Innerspring mattresses, even premium models, and brands, generally do not last longer than much higher end types such as memory foam or latex mattresses, due to the higher sagging rate of the mattress that significantly affects its longevity or lifespan. The average lifespan of spring or coil mattress beds is only up to 6 years or less while the best memory foam mattresses could last longer without any sagging issues. Top latex mattresses, on the other hand, is one of the longest lasting mattress types in the industry, with minimal to no sagging problems that could last for decades, especially with the right care and maintenance.

back to menu ↑

Pros and Cons of Spring Mattresses

PROS:
Spring mattresses are the most popular bed types for a number of reasons. First, this type of a mattress is much cheaper than other beds in the market. Good quality innerspring mattresses also last for years especially with proper maintenance, care, and use. Aside from consumer familiarity, innerspring mattresses are also widely available, and there are many firmness levels and comfort options to choose from, depending on the coil gauge and coil count.
CONS:
The downside of the spring mattress is basically on its below-average to average longevity and durability, not to mention the not-so-satisfactory performance on the pressure point and pain relief especially with low-end spring constructions. There could also be sagging problems over time and possible noise from the loose coil springs.

back to menu ↑

Comfort Test

Testing how the spring mattress feels and its comfort level, in general, is thoroughly validated if you essential lie on the bed surface to feel how comfortable it is. Put pressure on the mattress through your hand or palm and see how it responds to the weight exerted on its surface. Some beds are firmer, and others are so hard that you can feel the springs, while others have a bouncing effect.

Choosing the best innerspring mattress would mainly depend on your preferred kind of sleep position such as the medium-firm to soft level is ideal for side sleepers or lighter individuals as much firmer spring beds have a hard effect when there is less pressure or weight on the surface. Stomach and back sleepers, as well as heavier individuals, require a much firmer spring bed to ensure back support and protection of pressure points as firmer springs are known to provide a satisfactory effect to counter back pain and physiological discomforts.

back to menu ↑

Budget

Innerspring mattresses are quite popular due to their affordable and reasonable price. There are premium quality brands and models that have already been tested and proven for quality and performance. Some of the most affordable units with top quality features and designs include the Zinus innerspring collection, Signature Sleep, Serta, Sealy, and Saatva. Spring mattresses have cheap, mid-range and much costlier models depending on the design and manufacturing features of the bed. However, spending on coil spring beds makes a lot of sense especially with brands that are proven to last for years with minimal sagging and other pertinent issues.

TwinFullQueenKingCal. King
Median Price $432 $646 $756 $1224 $1487
Number Analyzed 199 244 268 225 141
It might be confusing to see median prices for bigger sizes of innerspring mattresses are higher than a similar size of memory mattresses. We’ve compared our data with the data of sleeplikethedead.com, and we see the same thing. So we’ve decided to dig further to understand why median prices of innerspring mattresses are higher than memory foam counterparts.  The reason behind this is that luxury market segment mostly consists of hybrid mattresses of foam and encased coils, however instead of being classified as hybrid, those are classified as innerspring mattresses. Real innerspring mattresses are mostly cheaper than memory foam ones.
back to menu ↑

Warranty and Trial Days

Different manufacturers offer varied warranty protection and trial period for their products. Warranties usually range between 5 and 25 years at the maximum for premium quality and high-end mattress models and brands. Trial periods also depend on the manufacturer but the typical time frame is from 30 to 120 days. Buying your spring mattress bed online does not give you a chance to do a comfort test before you purchase the unit, but manufacturers do offer trial periods and observe return policies so that you can have a hassle-free investment on your innerspring bed.

back to menu ↑

Conclusion

Spring or coil mattress beds are popular then and now and the continuous evolution and developments on this bed type are proof that the spring bed industry is not going anywhere soon. Spring beds have their share of pros and cons, but if you want a budget-friendly and affordable bed without sacrificing the quality, the innerspring selection is the best place to do your search. The best innerspring mattresses are usually the ones with pocket spring or custom patent designs, offering exceptional edge support, minimal motion transfer, and excellent body contouring abilities, however, there may be issues of noise over time, and those are not as durable as latex and memory foam beds are.

 

Login/Register access is temporary disabled